Coding Intel

Medical coding resources for physicians and their staff. CodingIntel was founded by consultant and coding expert Betsy Nicoletti.

  • Try Risk Free
  • Login
  • About
  • Free Resources
    • Nicoletti Notes Blog
    • Everyday Coding Q&A
    • Can I Get Paid
  • Member Resources
    • Home
    • Articles
    • Webinars
    • Quick Coding Cheat Sheets
    • Member Forum
    • Billing Guides
  • Coding Education
    • Live Webinars
    • On-Demand Webinars
    • Courses – Coming Soon!
  • My Account

Clues That Your Scribe is in Disguise

An Overview of Medical Scribes and Scribe Billing Rules

Medical scribes are in the news as a way for physicians to more effectively care for patients and use their EHRs. The scribe enters the exam room with the physician and does all of the data entry or typing while the physician takes the history, does and describes out loud the exam and develops the treatment plan with the patient. The physician scribe doesn’t interact directly with the patient at all, and probably isn’t the medical assistant who roomed the patient. The scribe writes, “Scribed by Betsy Nicoletti.” The physician reviews the scribed note, edits it and signs it.

But, sometimes, medical practices don’t understand the concept of a scribe and scribe billing rules. CodingIntel shares tell-tale clues that the person who is “scribing” isn’t really a scribe.

  • Instead of saying, “Scribed by Betsy Nicoletti” the note says, “Dictated for Dr. Palmisano.” Huge warning sign!
  • Your medical scribe is disguised as a student: Medical student services are never billable services, and a medical practice can’t use the student documentation as a basis for submitting a claim to an insurance company. It usually isn’t the model for students. The student doesn’t sit and type while the clinician asks questions and examines the patient, as a scribe does. In case you need more information on this, page down to my most recent post. This relates to PA and NP students, as well.
  • Your physician scribe is disguised as an NP or PA or physician with an advanced degree: But, the practice has neglected to enroll the PA or NP with insurances because the medical professional is “only filling in for this week” or “really never works on his/her own.” This is an enrollment issue. Medicare and Medicaid enroll physicians, NPs and PAs, so get them enrolled and report the services appropriately. Contracts with commercial insurers vary. In some models, the PA/NP sees the patient first, does the bulk of the documentation and then the physician arrives and does a briefer visit. Report that service under the PA/NP provider number. “Dictating for Dr. Orthopedist” is not scribing as defined above and does not allow you to report the service under Dr. Orthopedist’s NPI.
  • Your scribe is disguised as an NP or PA and is doing a procedure that typically only a physician or NP or PA would do. Re-read the above example. Your PA/NP may perform procedures independently or incident to. If independently, report under the NP/PA provider number. If incident to, be sure the Medicare incident to rules are met.
  • Your medical scribe is disguised as you, in the room without you, asking questions or doing an exam, disguised as an independent practitioner: Scribes are typically medical assistants trained to work with a clinician as a scribe in the room. They don’t ask questions, do a physical exam or formulate a tentative plan. They don’t interact with the patient. A scribe is like a fly on the wall, recording what happens in the exam room.

If you are using scribes, that is a terrific way to unchain a physician from data entry. But, look at the list above and make sure your medical scribe is really a scribe and complies with scribe billing rules. Don’t use the concept of scribing as a way to not enroll eligible professionals.

Would you like more resources on medical scribes and scribe billing rules, or detailed information on the importance of physician scribes? Become a member of CodingIntel today.

Want more information on medical coding?

Join CodingIntel for customized coding and billing education.

Become a member!

Accurate at time of posting: June 11, 2014
by Betsy Nicoletti
Tagged With: billing, coding, Compliance, Medicare rules

  • About
  • FAQs
  • Terms of Use
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact

Our mission is to provide accurate, comprehensive, up-to-date coding answers, allowing medical practices to increase revenue, decrease coding denials and reduce compliance risk. That's what coding knowledge can do.

In 1988, CodingIntel.com founder Betsy Nicoletti started a Medical Services Organization for a rural hospital, supporting physician practice. She has been a self-employed consultant since 1998. She estimates that in the last 20 years her audience members number over 22,100 at in person events and webinars. She has had 2,500 meetings with clinical providers and reviewed over 40,000 medical notes. She knows what questions need answers and developed this resource to answer those questions. For more about Betsy visit www.betsynicoletti.com.

no show
  • Try Risk Free
  • Login

Copyright 2018, CodingIntel